Sent: Saturday, April 14, 2001 3:28
PM
Subject: Distortion of History
The Editor
The Halifax Herald
April 14,2001
Dear Editor:
There is clearly no end to the diatribe you
reproduce from The New York Times about the
Palestine/Israel conflict and Islam today {John Burns "The Peace
Breakers" April 14}.
The killing of children and civlian men and
women is appalling, be they Jews, Christians or Muslims. Mr. Burns brings up the
tragic killing of the Israeli child in the settlement in Hebron, but no mention
of the hundreds of Palestinian children killed or maimed for life. He states
that the killing of this Israeli child "prompted U.S. President George W.
Bush, in Washington, to demand that Arafat "stop the violence".
Clearly, President Bush was not prompted to call on Sharon to stop the killing
of hundreds of Palestinian men, women and children, the extrajudicial
assassinations , the demolition of Palestinian homes, expropriation of their
property or to call for an end to the illegal Israeli occupation that has been
allowed to stand for 34 years, in defiance of international law, The
Fourth Geneva Convention and repeated Security Council
resolutions.
He speaks of the threat of Islamic militants
"mastering a new generation of chemical, biological and even nuclear
weapons". There is no mention of the fact that Israel is already in
possession of these weapons. Some readers may remember Daniel Paul's column in
The Halifax Herald :{'Where is the outrage over
Israel's work on Biological weapon" Jan. 15,1999}, referring to the report
in The Sunday Herald { The Ethnic Bomb: Israeli weapon
would kill Arabs, spare Jews" Nov. 15, 1998.} This report was taken from
The Sunday Times of London, authored by Uzi Mahnaimi
and Marie Colvin, quoting Israeli scientists and politicians. Similar work on
chemical weapons at the same Israeli institution, Nes Tziona,
was confirmed by The Netherlands government after the crash of the
Israeli airliner El Al in Amsterdam in 1992
{The Globe and Mail , Feb. 8, 1999}. Reports are
coming out now from physicians in Gaza reporting Israeli use of chemical
weapons.
Mr Burns accuses Islam of encouragement to
kill idolaters. Let me remind him that Islam preached tolerance to "The
people of the Book", including Jews and Christians and practiced that, as
historically documented, more than any other faith. The first Khalifah in Islam,
Abu Bakr, in the year 634 A.D, ordered the commander, Usama Ibn Zayd, of the
troops sent to Palestine and Syria :" Do not deceive or cheat and do not
torture and do not kill a child or an elderly person or a woman and do not cut a
tree or slay a cow or a sheep or a camel. You will find people in their
churches and places of worship; do not molest them or harm them". These
were The Fourth Geneva Convention, written 1400 years ago. Let
me contrast this with the soldiers of the Hebrew Tribes besieging Jericho
,quoting The Book of Joshua, so often invoked today in the Israeli Army
rabbinate, to put everyone "to the edge of the sword ...both man and woman,
young and old" [Joshua vi, 21]. Tragically, we have witnessed this week
this madness expressed by Former Chief Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, the spiritual leader
of the ultra-orthodox Shas Party in his passover sermon in Jerusalem calling on
God for the annihilation of all the Arabs and stating :" It is forbidden to
be merciful to them, you must give them missiles, with relish - annihilate them.
Evil ones, damnable ones".
I think an element of balance and fairness to
Palestinians and Islam is called for, and the readers of The Herald
deserve that.
Yours sincerely
Ismail Zayid, MD.