Sent: Sunday, July 06, 2003 5:04 
PM
Subject: Israel's good intentions 
?!!
 
 
 
July 6,2003
 
The Editor
Guardian Weekly.
 
Dear Editor:
 
The charges, made in David Quentzel' letter {"Trust Israel 
good intentions" June 26} against Suzanne Goldenberg's reports, are baseless and 
defy factual history. The Palestinians are the victims 
of a systematic Zionist programme of ethnic cleansing and dispossession 
formulated by all Zionist leaders, from Theodor Herzl to Ariel 
Sharon. This policy of ethnic cleansing was largely effected in early 1948, 
with the eviction of 350,000 refugees and the occupation of scores of cities and 
towns, like Jaffa and Acre, that were allotted to the Arab state in UN 
Resolution #181, before a single Arab soldier entered Palestine 
on May 15,1948.
 
In June 1967 Israel initiated its planned war of 
aggression against Egypt, Jordan and Syria, resulting in the 
illegal occupation of Arab territories that include to this day 
the Palestinian territories of the West Bank,including East Jerusalem, and Gaza, 
as well as the Syrian Golan Heights. This illegal occupation has been allowed 
to stand for 36 years in defiance of international law and repeated 
Security Council resolutions. The claim by Israel's apologists that the June 
1967 war was a pre-emptive war against threats from President Nasser are 
demolished by Israel's leaders' own testimony. Yitzhak Rabin, Israel's chief of 
staff at the time stated: " I do not think Nasser wanted war. The two divisions 
he sent to the Sinai would not have been sufficient to launch an offensive 
war. He knew it and we knew it." {Le Monde. Feb.28,1968}. Menachem 
Begin, a cabinet minister at the time, stated, when he was prime minister, 
addressing Israel's National Defence College. on Aug.8,1982, : " In June 1967, 
we again had a choice. The Egyptian army concentrations in the Sinai did 
not prove that Nasser was really about to attack us. We must be honest with 
ourselves. We decided to attack him." [The New York Times. Aug. 21,1982}. 
Perhaps, it is time that Mr. Quentzel and other Israeli apologists heed Mr, 
Begin's advice and practice some honesty on this score. This war of aggression 
by Israel was only one of many. Those include Israel's war of aggression against 
Egypt in 1956, in collusion with Britain and France, as well its wars of 
aggression against Lebanon in 1978 and 1982. We are still waiting for the 
penalties and financial compensation paid by the aggressor, as Mr. Quentzel 
suggests.
 
The Palestinians, under illegal occupation for the last 36 years, 
have been the victims of the most oppressive occupation, the practices of which 
include extra-judicial assassination, detention without charge or trial, 
torture, daily humiliation,demolition of thousands of their homes and 
expropriation of their land for the creation of illegal Jewish settlements. 
These oppressive acts are all in violation of the Fourth Geneva 
Convention,  and are,as defined by international law, war 
crimes.The Barak charade at Camp David,in July 2000, that Mr. Quentzel 
refers to as " an extraordinary package offered by Israel;" defies all logic. 
The Palestinians are not calling for any generosity from Israel. They are 
calling for complete  termination of this illegal 
occupation and Israeli compliance with international law and UN 
resolutions.
 
How long must Israel be allowed to remain above international law 
?
 
Yours sincerely,
 
Ismail Zayid, M.D.